Image not available

1079x1039

1000034481.jpg

๐Ÿงต Question?

Anonymous No. 16173975

If a land area of 208 hectares can become a country (Monaco) and accede to the United Nations.

Can an island of 253 hectares do the same if it has the backing of a permanent UN member of the Security Council?

Anonymous No. 16173981

yes, if enough money is involved

Anonymous No. 16174041

>>16173975
God didn't decide what is a country, other countries do. So yes if you convince other countries to agree that what ever you have is a country then it's a country. Good luck I guess lmao

Anonymous No. 16174169

>>16173975
The UN is not a country registry bureau

Anonymous No. 16174204

>>16174169
The United Nations is the sole body that grants a country its sovereignty and recognition internationally.

Anonymous No. 16174304

>>16174204
Totally wrong. The UN has no such authority. Sovereignty and recognition are matters of consensus, not declaration.

Anonymous No. 16174386

>>16174204
>The United Nations is the sole body that grants a country its sovereignty and recognition internationally.

Oh so countries didnt exist before 1945?

Anonymous No. 16174634

>>16173975
Its a country if you can maintain control over it and defend it from foreign law enforcement and militaries (especially whatever country was formerly in control of your island), or convince another country to guarantee your territorial integrity.
Everything else is formalities.

Image not available

262x237

1700796128723370.jpg

Anonymous No. 16174668

>>16174634
>or convince another country to guarantee your territorial integrity.

Anonymous No. 16174683

>>16174668
works for israel (so far)

Anonymous No. 16174853

Sovereignty comes from strength. Land only belongs to a group capable of defending it.

Anonymous No. 16175021

bump

Anonymous No. 16175701

>>16174668
>or convince another country to guarantee your territorial integrity.
Why is this controversial for you?

Anonymous No. 16175761

>>16175701
it is not
but we all know which country it is

Anonymous No. 16175781

>>16175761
Tuvalu?

Anonymous No. 16175787

>>16175761
Ah, a reference to Israel. Tell you what, very few countries can hold their own in a military sense, for instance Costa Rica doesnt have an army of any sorts. Countries exist in practice as client states of some larger super power that offers them security guarantees in return for signaling allegiance.

Anonymous No. 16176709

>>16174304
No you have the cases of Taiwan, Kosovo and Palestine which are technically countries but are not recognised by the members of the UN Security Council.

Anonymous No. 16176926

>>16173975
yes if the Vatican City and Monaco can become countries, why not.

Anonymous No. 16177102

>>16174386
They did exist but there was the league of nations.

Anonymous No. 16177167

>>16173975
In the brains of the nationalists almost anything is possible, perhaps anything even.

Anonymous No. 16177233

>>16177102
>but there was the league of nations.
oh so there were no countries before the league of nations?

Anonymous No. 16177284

>>16173975
"Country status" is not some checklist. It's not awarded. It's implemented, as facts on the ground.

You just need to convince enough relevant countries, to treat you like a country, then you are a country.
How you do that? Well, for example having a title of "Count" and being a principality that stretches back for several centuries is a pretty good argument that exposes you as a non-LARPer.

Anonymous No. 16177306

>>16173975
Monaco has a lot rich people influences and casinos.

Anonymous No. 16177848

>>16175787
>Countries exist in practice as client states of some larger super power that offers them security guarantees in return for signaling allegiance.
weird how it's US politicians who literally get on their hands and knees and kiss the feet of visiting big wigs from our "loyal little client state"

Image not available

1061x2424

1000034681.jpg

Anonymous No. 16178147

>>16177284
>"Country status" is not some checklist

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montevideo_Convention

Anonymous No. 16178155

>>16178147
>capacity to enter into relations with the other states
This is where most fail.

Anonymous No. 16178395

bump

Anonymous No. 16178648

>>16178147
The implication you are making (this document is relevant to statehood) is equivalent to the statement that before this piece of toilet paper was written, there were no states/countries.

Anonymous No. 16178770

>>16177848
guess you found who the real super power is
its true, also the part about signaling allegiance. When a country declares it stands with Israel that country will be protected too and allowed to trade within the Israel global block

Anonymous No. 16179033

Personally I've no problems with Israel itself. It's the Jews not in Israel that are the problem.

Anonymous No. 16179183

>>16173975
there is mostly another country which this 253 hectores belong.
so if that goverment says/ ok its your country now. then its ok i guess.
But what country/goverment will do that ?

Anonymous No. 16179187

>>16173975
Science & Math?