🧵 Does Lineage Matter?
Anonymous at Sun, 26 Nov 2023 20:35:09 UTC No. 177002
Pic related. Does lineage matter, does it matter where you train and who they trained under?
Anonymous at Sun, 26 Nov 2023 20:49:35 UTC No. 177006
Sort of. Isn't a guarantee of anything usually, but these days it's harder to fake a good rep for whatever. But you could be a world champ and whoever is "training" you could be completely incompetent beyond that one fighter.
Anonymous at Sun, 26 Nov 2023 21:02:24 UTC No. 177007
>>177002
If it's an old martial art yes, bjj no.
Anonymous at Sun, 26 Nov 2023 21:03:27 UTC No. 177008
>>177002
It matters of your teacher is making certain claims. And generally speaking, teachers who lie about their lineage often don't produce great practical results.
Anonymous at Thu, 30 Nov 2023 19:25:27 UTC No. 177581
>>177002
Are you a weeb faggot obsessed with identifying with a specific antiquated style?
>Yes.
Do you care more about function than any other aspect of martial arts?
>No.
Anonymous at Thu, 30 Nov 2023 20:25:51 UTC No. 177588
People will often conflate the ability of the instructor with the ability of the students
For example: Matt Serra was a former UFC champion, so one might say "wow that guys a black belt under Matt Serra", but matt produces a lot of shitty black belts especially these days because he just phones it in and doesn't care anymore
Contrast that with Danaher who has no accolades in competition whatsoever and produces some of the finest students
I use them as examples because they're both renzo black belts from the same era
One of them innovates the other teaches the same stuff he learned in the 90s
Look more at the quality of someone's student body more than their own personal accomplishments
Anonymous at Sat, 2 Dec 2023 17:49:31 UTC No. 177880
Should schools be using their lineage as a marketing strategy? Would that get more people interested or do only nerds care about that? Me personally I think it's really cool if someone is a Rickson blackbelt because he only has like a dozen or so right? Seems like something special. idk
Anonymous at Sat, 2 Dec 2023 17:56:22 UTC No. 177881
>>177880
>he only has like a dozen
He probably charges a million dollar per hour to train someone.
Anonymous at Sat, 2 Dec 2023 18:30:29 UTC No. 177888
>>177880
Most already do. Either passively with pictures on walls and social media, or if they're in an association then that tends to have either someone's name or easily referenced phrasing of a style. IE anyone listing American Kenpo is almost certainly associated with Ed Parker, RGA is Renzo Gracie Association, etc.
Anonymous at Sat, 2 Dec 2023 19:12:18 UTC No. 177899
>>177880
If you knew fuck all about Rickson you wouldn't think so. He's a bullshido artist who has been making outrageous claims so fucking retatd his own daddy went public and said he is full of shit. Rickson JJ has not produced a single champ, there are no pro-mma fighters from Rickson's schools.
Anonymous at Mon, 4 Dec 2023 04:48:49 UTC No. 178063
>>177899
>there are no pro-mma fighters from Rickson's schools.
Not true at all.
Anonymous at Mon, 4 Dec 2023 05:03:30 UTC No. 178065
>>178063
Look at what a disgrace his son is
Fall atop me and meet your doom!
Anonymous at Mon, 4 Dec 2023 21:34:12 UTC No. 178170
>>177002
If that lineage helps you become a better martial artist, sure. But nothing beats the combination of
-ideal environment
-good genetics
-early skill acquisition
-good conditioning and strength training
-training based on specificity and competition
Anonymous at Tue, 5 Dec 2023 17:51:42 UTC No. 178289
>>178063
Name 1 faggot. I don't speak out of turn, I checked first. You are wrong.
Anonymous at Tue, 5 Dec 2023 17:53:53 UTC No. 178290
>>178063
>>178065
And his faggot fucking loser sons do not count because they sucked more donkey dong than a Tiajuana hooker.
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 05:41:14 UTC No. 179442
>>178290
why does rickson bother you so much
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 07:16:25 UTC No. 179447
>>179442
The whole family is overrated grifters
Rickson claims he has a perfect 400-0 professional fighting record
He makes frank dux tier claims but people just look the other way with it
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 17:50:37 UTC No. 179480
>>179447
why are you posting in a bjj thread then if it's all bullshit and a hoax
rickson has videos of fights you can watch my dude
his black belts and people under him have gone on to fight professionally, my coach is a bb under a bb under a rickson bb.
why are you so mad lmao
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 19:00:37 UTC No. 179484
>>179480
He has in his entire career 11 documented professional fights
He claims over 400
Winning a few fights legitimately does not make him less of a fraud
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 20:01:30 UTC No. 179487
>>179480
>why are you so mad lmao
The typical "I hate the popular thing" 4chan mentality
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 21:01:29 UTC No. 179491
>>179480
Why are you being such a butthurt BJJ bitch? Did you miss the part where his own Daddy said he is full of shit? He is a fraud no matter how many cope arguments you make. He had to branch off and form his own school cause he wouldn't knock off the bullshit, that's why he's not even a Humaita affiliate.
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 21:12:14 UTC No. 179492
>>179491
and amazingly rickson was the voice of reason when rener was selling blue belts online so just imagine the kind of slop gracie academy HQ is churning out
Anonymous at Thu, 14 Dec 2023 21:25:56 UTC No. 179495
>>179492
Well he ain't so reasonable anymore, read the thread dude>>177914 He does the same fucking thing. Seems like he was just mad someone was stepping on his toes.
Anonymous at Sat, 16 Dec 2023 04:56:10 UTC No. 179701
>>177002
Depends, if its like eastern arts where its all oral teaching then id say maybe?
If its like western martial arts where theres hundreds of years of written manuals and various living lineages then no. But western martial arts is really wonky with lineage because of how constantly changing it was.
Shit becomes wonky when its westerners learning eastern styles so i always assume its mostly bullshit
>>177588
Yeah, one of my HEMA teachers isnt the best at teaching (despite being an excellent fencer) but he does create some good students. But his problem is more he cant simplify basic stuff but is great at teaching advanced concepts.
>>177581
Pretty much this. At the end of the day, its all a big LARP.
Anonymous at Sat, 16 Dec 2023 07:21:18 UTC No. 179711
>>177002
It can; it’s definitely true that the quality of a teacher will influence how their students turn out, if we extrapolate from this it’s true that a teacher’s teacher will have some influence on whomever the student is. But it’s not an end all be all, someone with a meh teacher can still make up for it if they apply themselves, and there are plenty of people with great teachers who will end up being mediocre if they’re just untalented or whatever.
Anonymous at Sun, 17 Dec 2023 00:17:45 UTC No. 179805
>>177002
To a degree.
Suppose someone is a black belt under, say, John Danaher. It's then safe to assume that this person is pretty damn good at grappling. They might not be great at passing the knowledge on, teaching is a skill of its own, but having that black belt under a very reputable coach is at the very least a proof that they're not talking out of their ass.
Anonymous at Fri, 26 Jan 2024 23:51:47 UTC No. 184182
>>177002
Lineage is a proxy. It lets you know that the person has actual bona fides and learned from people who know what they are doing/saying. It doesn't mean they're skilled or good at teaching, but it helps weed out fakes and know-nothings.
If you had a choice to learn boxing from someone who was taught by Tyson, or someone who was taught by a guy neither you nor google has ever heard of, who do you think is more likely to have a good understanding of boxing?
Anonymous at Sun, 28 Jan 2024 06:58:13 UTC No. 184400
>>177002
Honestly, yeah. Coaching dynasties exist in many sports. Does it matter for your strip mall BJJ place? Not really.